CPCBA Sermon: Enough

 
 

When God's Generosity Challenges Our Ideas of Fairness

Rev. Heather Schoenewolf | November 15, 2026 | Twenty-Fifth Sunday After Pentecost

Scripture Readings: Exodus 16:1–16 and Matthew 20:1–16

"It's not fair!"

We've all said it. But what happens when God's generosity doesn't follow our expectations of fairness?

In her sermon “Enough,” Rev. Heather Schoenewolf explores Jesus' parable of the vineyard workers, where those who work all day receive the same wages as those hired just an hour before quitting time.

The story challenges our assumptions about fairness, deserving, and God's surprising generosity.

When Everyone Receives Enough

The workers who labored all day expect more than those who arrived late. When everyone receives the same wage, they protest.

Heather acknowledges that genuine injustice deserves our attention, particularly when some have plenty while others go hungry. But Jesus' parable asks a different question: Why should another person's good fortune diminish our own?

God Is Not Fair. God Is Generous.

Heather draws on theologian Barbara Brown Taylor's striking observation:

"God is not fair. God is generous."

God's love isn't distributed according to accomplishments or social standing. It extends to those who succeed and those who struggle.

As Heather reminds us:

"God blesses those who work hard all day. And God blesses those who cannot find steady work no matter how hard they try."

Living Generously Together

Preached on CPCBA's Generosity Sunday, the sermon invites us to consider how we share our blessings.

Heather celebrates members who prepare meals, repair the sanctuary, support the free market with Beloved Community Church, teach Sunday school, and contribute to worship.

"Friends, we are God's beloved community. We have been blessed by the gifts of a generous God."

These everyday acts demonstrate what it means to share our time, talent, and treasure in partnership with God.

Questions for Reflection

  • When have you struggled to celebrate someone else's good fortune?

  • How might our communities change if ensuring everyone has enough mattered more than determining who deserves more?

  • What blessings could you share more generously?

Ultimately, “Enough” reminds us that God's abundance isn't about receiving more than our neighbors. It's about recognizing what we've been given and finding joy in sharing it.

“Enough” was preached November 15, 2026, at Community Presbyterian Church of Ben Avon. Explore more sermons or join us for worship at cpcba.org.

Read the sermon

Generous God, we come to you with thanksgiving, with thanksgiving for this time together and for your many blessings. We give you thanks for your word to us. And we pray that by the power of your Spirit, we will draw near to your word and be transformed, that we might live into the economy of your grace. And so may the words of my mouth and the meditation of all of our hearts be acceptable to you, O God, for you are our rock and our redeemer. Amen.

So this is one of those passages that we could talk about for a really long time, but it is our Thanksgiving feast, so you're only going to get one sermon out of me today. But if you want to keep talking, you know where to find me.

It's not fair.

"It's not fair" is a complaint as old as time. And if I asked anyone here in the sanctuary who has ever uttered such a phrase to raise your hand, probably everyone's hand would go up. Mine would.

A few weeks ago, I shared with you the story of the toast that my father-in-law offered at my wedding. And today, I can't help but share—I feel like I would be remiss if I did not share—that my father quoted from this very passage in his toast at my wedding.

As you know, I am one of three sisters, and I'm the oldest, and I am the last married woman of the bunch. And so my father, in front of all of our guests, mentioned this quote: "The last shall be first and the first shall be last."

And I will admit that, particularly as he cited this gospel lesson, his toast was well played. Because as a dad of three girls—and my mom, as a mom of three girls, is probably worshiping with us on Zoom—they heard their fair share of the cry, "But it's not fair!" in their house.

Like the laborers who arrived first in the vineyard, I too raised my fair share of complaints about what was not fair in the economy of our family.

I share this with my sister's permission, but my sister said, "If they come to church, don't ask them about it."

But I could share. She said, "I would say, like, it was not fair that the youngest sister did not have to wait till her birthday to get a Cabbage Patch doll like the oldest two did. She got her Cabbage Patch doll on my birthday. It's not fair!"

And it was not fair that my younger sisters got to have the same curfew as me because I was their ride.

All right, the list could go on. And yes, I can hear myself: the entitlement, the whining, the misplaced priorities. This is as much of a confession as it is a story.

For there is a need, as we know, to cry out about the things in this world that really are not fair. When God provides enough daily bread for all, but some hoard while others go hungry. That list could go on.

But this passage reminds us that while there is a need to cry out against the unfairness of the world, it is more than a child's silliness to cry foul when someone simply has the same good that you have received.

And somewhere tucked inside each one of us, we might also admit that there's this small part of us that is like those laborers in the vineyard.

Now, Jesus knew it, too. Jesus knew what people are like, as we heard this parable in our gospel. And he tells a story of workers in the vineyard who labored for their fair wage.

There was a group hired at the break of day, but throughout the day, the landowner went out and hired more and more workers to labor in his vineyard, some coming to the field just an hour before the end of the workday.

And at the end of the day, when everyone lined up to receive their pay, the foreman was told, "First pay those who got here last."

And soon all of the workers saw that the last to arrive got their promised wage.

Those who spent the entire day in the fields grew expectant when they saw that those who had worked only an hour received the same wage that they had been promised. Surely, they thought, they would get more.

And when they didn't, they argued back, saying, "It's not fair."

Now, it's interesting to note, if we flip through the pages of our Bible—and I invite you to look at the chapter before and the rest of the chapter that follows—this parable, this story that Jesus told to his disciples, is situated within a larger text.

And like I say, we have got to pay attention to the larger context to get to the heart of the story.

Now, it's interesting to note that the entire chapter that precedes it is a chapter in which, over and over, questions of human gatekeeping are brought before Jesus. People come to Jesus with the expectation that Jesus will ratify the social contracts that create castes of inequity among people.

Immediately before this story is the famous story of the rich man lamenting that Jesus calls him to give his wealth to the poor in order to fully follow him. And the end of that chapter concludes with the line that concluded our reading for today: "Many of those who will be first will be last, and many of the last will be first."

And in very human fashion, as if for good measure, after Jesus teaches this parable, he is approached by the mother of James and John, who asks if her two boys could please have the best seats in heaven, one at the right hand of Jesus and one to his left.

And again, Jesus reminds her, "The last will be first and the first will be last."

See, all throughout this section of Matthew's gospel, Jesus teaches over and over again, reminding God's people, God's closest disciples, that God's ways are not always our ways.

And let's face it, this truth is sometimes hard to hear.

We can get squirmy. We can make a rationale, because if we can create systems that make it clear what's required of us to receive our reward, maybe we can actually find security in our own efforts.

Maybe we can elevate our own best offerings above another. Maybe we can make sure that we will reap our reward without needing to fear that others will be rewarded, too.

But see, in spite of our human tendency to manufacture rubrics of fairness, the message we receive in return challenges us again and again with a claim that is not so comfortable.

And that claim is: God is not fair.

At least not according to human standards.

Barbara Brown Taylor writes this:

"God is not fair for reasons we may never know. God seems to love us indiscriminately and seems also to enjoy reversing the systems we set up to explain why God should love some of us more than others."

God's not fair. But depending on where you are in that line, that can sound like powerful good news.

Because if God's not fair, then there is a chance that we will get paid more than we are worth. That we will get more than we deserve. That we will make it through the doors even though we are last in line. Not because of who we are, but because of who God is.

She goes on to say, "God is not fair. God is generous."

And when we begrudge that generosity, it is only because we have forgotten where we stand.

See, we gather today to worship a generous God who gives not according to the forms of etiquette we've constructed in this world, but with the unabashed freedom that comes from one whose first purpose and unabashed aim is to love.

God blesses those who work hard all day. And God blesses those who cannot find steady work no matter how hard they try.

God blesses those who show up at the expected time and those who wait patiently for an affirmation that they are welcomed and valued.

God blesses those whose jaws drop with gratitude at the many gifts God has given them.

God blesses even those who balk at the fact that God has blessed someone else.

Now, today we have dubbed Generosity Sunday in the life of our church, and we are reminded not only today, but always, that Christ calls us continually to live into the economy of God.

For in this realm, there is a recognition of the blessings we have received. There is a prioritization of sharing those blessings to care for the well-being of all. There is a commitment to giving what we have received to further the gospel of grace.

Because, astonishingly, a world in which humankind was committed to ensuring the well-being of all would be a world without need. For God is a God who provides.

And so today, our invitation is to consider how we might give generously of our time and our talent and our treasure so that we can join with God, so that we can partner with God in this ministry of grace.

Yes, we will receive the offering today, and we will receive pledge cards. And we will estimate what it is that we have to give of our time, our talent, and our treasure for the work of Christ here in this church, and dedicate ourselves to Christ's glory.

But even as I stand here today, I continually wish that you all had a turn to sit up here. And if you would like one, we can make that happen, because then you too would look out and see those who are a blessing here in this place.

See, God has blessed us already with those who made turkey casserole and those who swept the debris from the wall and patched and hung the television over here; those who performed in a production on this chancel last night and then pulled together the elements of our worship service; those who served at the free market with Beloved Community Church and those who dropped off donations in the doorway; those who planned Sunday school classroom lessons and those who colored centerpieces for the Thanksgiving meal.

The list goes on.

Friends, we are God's beloved community.

We have been blessed by the gifts of a generous God. And if we look around, we can see how robust those blessings are.

And so may we, with joy, may we with gratitude, and may we with hope and love, give generously in partnership with God so that we together can proclaim the good news of God's gracious love.

Friends, may it be so. Amen.

Previous
Previous

Phishing Email Alert

Next
Next

Pray-Ground Rules